A Tanker Hit a Docked Riverboat in New Orleans. The Port Sued the Tanker Itself

A tanker that lost steering rolled the docked riverboat American Heritage. All survived. Then the port sued the ship itself.

How we work: facts are checked against original sources and linked, cruise prices are verified on the cruise line’s own website the day we publish, and we earn no commissions. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will correct it.

The cruise was over. The American Heritage, a five-deck paddlewheeler, had been tied up in New Orleans for about two hours at the end of an eight-day Mississippi River trip, and guests were getting off.

Then a 160-metre asphalt tanker coming up the river veered and hit her.

Within minutes she was listing, then on her side, with passengers and crew in the water. Everyone survived. By that evening, the Port of New Orleans had gone to federal court to have the tanker seized. Not the captain. The ship.

American Cruise Lines paddlewheel riverboat, then named Queen of the Mississippi, docked at Dubuque
American Heritage as Queen of the Mississippi, Dubuque, Iowa, 2016. Photo: Benroethig, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What Happened at Mile 96

On Friday, November 13, the Marshall Islands-flagged tanker Atlantic Asphalt struck American Cruise Lines’ American Heritage while she was moored outside the Port of New Orleans Administration Building, near mile marker 96 on the Lower Mississippi. The tanker’s manager, OSM Thome, and WGNO put the time at about 12:30 p.m.; the NTSB’s case page says about 1:02 p.m.

Coast Guard Capt. Melanie Burnham said there “seems to be some type of a loss of steering,” the BBC reported, and the Associated Press said the boat flipped while rescuers were still getting people off. Harbor Police, port staff, tugboat crews and other vessels pulled people out of 66°F water. Mayor Helena Moreno called it “a miracle on the Mississippi.”

🛳️ The week's verified cruise deals, every Friday

Every fare checked on the cruise line's own site. We'll also send your free Cruise Survival Kit right away, with a printable packing checklist and money-saving cheat sheet.

Send me the deals →

Headcounts vary: about 129 passengers plus crew (the port, early on), 180 (the mayor, via AP), 191 (Fox 8) and 197 passengers and crew (the port’s own Friday evening statement, quoted by Cruise Hive). What everyone agrees on: nobody died, and 32 people went to hospital, none critically, two of them Harbor Police officers.

The First 48 Hours

WhenWhat
Fri, ~12:30 p.m.Atlantic Asphalt, heading upriver, hits the docked American Heritage. The Coast Guard closes the river between miles 93 and 96.
FriNTSB investigators can’t fly in, because all US flights are grounded by communications problems at regional air traffic control centers. The team travels by road instead.
Fri eveningThe port sues the tanker, its owner and its manager in federal court. A warrant directs US marshals to seize and hold the tanker.
SatThe tanker is towed to the Perry Street Wharf in Gretna. Eight people are still in hospital, two serious but stable. NTSB recovers the tanker’s voyage data recorder.
Sat–SunCarnival Valor and Carnival Liberty sail from New Orleans on schedule. Their terminal is under a mile away.

Burnham said salvage would take “weeks,” starting with the 16,000 gallons of fuel still aboard the riverboat, according to NBC News and Fox 8. The NTSB expects a preliminary report within 30 days and a final one in 18 to 24 months.

Red cargo ship passing the Crescent City Connection bridge on the Mississippi River at New Orleans under a blue sky
A cargo ship passes the Crescent City Connection, the bridge the tanker had just come under. Photo: Infrogmation of New Orleans, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why a Big Ship Can’t Just Stop

Tulane maritime law professor Martin Davies told AP that tankers here carry local pilots, and that Atlantic Asphalt had already made “the difficult Algiers Point turn” before it struck. “For something like this to happen for an upbound ship indicates that something must have gone really badly wrong,” he said.

A ship without steering keeps moving. Atlantic Asphalt is a 17,764-deadweight-tonne tanker, per OSM Thome; American Heritage measures 2,700 gross tons. A city riverfront offers nowhere to drift.

What failed is for the NTSB to establish. Its board member John DeLeeuw compared the tanker’s voyage data recorder, which holds speed and bridge audio among other data, to an aircraft’s flight recorder. Until then, “loss of steering” is an early read, not a finding.

The asphalt tanker Atlantic Asphalt underway on the Cape Fear River in North Carolina
Atlantic Asphalt on the Cape Fear River, North Carolina. Photo: Gerry Dincher, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

New Orleans Has Seen This Before

On December 14, 1996, the loaded Liberian bulk carrier Bright Field temporarily lost propulsion heading downriver and hit the Poydras Street Wharf beside the Riverwalk shopping mall and a Hilton hotel. Nobody died, but 4 people were seriously hurt and 58 had minor injuries during evacuations of shore buildings, a casino boat and an excursion boat. Damage came to about $20 million. The NTSB later blamed the owner’s poor oversight of engine-room maintenance.

That report was adopted in January 1998, 13 months after the accident. Expect a similar wait here.

New Orleans riverfront with the Riverwalk, a paddlewheeler and the Crescent City Connection over the Mississippi
The Riverwalk, bottom right, where the freighter Bright Field hit the wharf in 1996. Photo: Eira Tansey, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Port Sued the Ship. Literally.

The port’s lawsuit, filed in the Eastern District of Louisiana, names three defendants: the owner Nave Shipping SA, the manager Thome Ship Management, and “the Atlantic Asphalt MV” itself. It says the Thalia Street Terminal was “significantly damaged,” with physical damage “currently estimated to exceed $1,000,000,” and blames the “negligence, gross negligence, fault or carelessness of the Atlantic Asphalt” (Fox 8, BBC). Those are allegations, and none has been tested in court.

Suing a ship is ordinary admiralty law. Supplemental Rule C of the federal civil rules says an action against the vessel itself, “in rem,” “may be brought… To enforce any maritime lien.” The port says the damage gives it exactly that kind of lien. Held by marshals, the tanker can’t sail away from the bill. We’ve seen the same move against a casino ship over a shipyard bill.

The lawsuit also calls it an “allision,” the legal word for a moving ship hitting a stationary one. That matters because of an 1895 Supreme Court case, The Oregon, whose syllabus describes a presumption in favour of a vessel at anchor “receiving injuries through the fault of a steamer in motion.” In plain terms, the ship that was standing still starts with the benefit of the doubt.

What the Passengers’ Contract Says

Here’s the awkward part. The port could arrest the tanker. American Cruise Lines’ passengers have agreed not to do that to its boats. Section 11(B) of the line’s current published terms says the passenger “waives any right he or she may have to an in rem or quasi in rem proceeding to arrest or attach any of ACL’s vessels.”

The same document has deadlines that are easy to miss:

  • Lost belongings: written notice “within 30 (thirty) days” and a lawsuit within six months.
  • Personal injury: written notice within six months and a lawsuit within one year.
  • The cap: liability for baggage contents is limited to “$100 per passenger,” and phones, cameras, cash and jewellery are excluded.

Caveats: a guest’s ticket may be an older edition, and the contract covers claims against American Cruise Lines. The tanker’s owners never signed it.

Red and white paddlewheel riverboat on the Mississippi River at New Orleans near the bridge
A paddlewheeler on the Mississippi at New Orleans, 2023. Photo: Mussi Katz, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What to Take From This Before Your Next River Cruise

The mayor’s account of the aftermath reads like a packing list: survivors had lost IDs and car keys, and some had no phones.

  • Keep a copy of your ID somewhere other than your bag: a photo in cloud storage or with someone at home. Our cruise ID guide covers what you need to replace.
  • Read the claims section of your contract before you sail. Thirty days passes fast when you’re getting home and seeing doctors.
  • Don’t rely on the cruise line for your belongings. A $100 cap that excludes electronics means your own travel insurance or home policy is what actually covers you.
  • Take the safety briefing seriously, even on a river. This boat rolled at the dock. Know where the life jackets are, as on a big-ship muster drill.

Nobody died. A court holds the tanker, the NTSB holds its recorder, and the guests, if their tickets match today’s terms, have 30 days to claim for what they lost.

Cruise Chaos earns nothing from cruise lines and doesn’t run booking affiliate links. The cause is unconfirmed, and the port’s claims are allegations. Reports differ on headcounts and the impact time, so we give each. Contract quotes are from the terms published on November 15, 2026. Not legal advice. If we’ve got something wrong, tell us and we’ll correct it in the open.


Got a cruise story like this?

Something wild, strange or funny happened on your sailing? Tell us what happened. We read every story, fact-check it, and email you before anything is published.

Share your story →

Keep Reading

Sources

🛳️ The Week’s Verified Cruise Deals, Every Friday

Every fare checked on the cruise line’s own site. Join the crew and we’ll also send your free Cruise Survival Kit right away, with a printable packing checklist and money-saving cheat sheet.

We’ll never send you spam or share your email address.
Find out more in our Privacy Policy.

🛳️ The Week’s Verified Cruise Deals, Every Friday

Every fare checked on the cruise line’s own site. Join the crew and we’ll also send your free Cruise Survival Kit right away, with a printable packing checklist and money-saving cheat sheet.

We’ll never send you spam or share your email address.
Find out more in our Privacy Policy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *