A Catamaran Tried to Arrest Scarlet Lady. An Insurer’s Letter Set Her Free.

A Rhodes catamaran owner asked a court to seize Scarlet Lady over EUR 400,000 in damage. Why she sailed anyway, and what your ticket says.

How we work: facts are checked against original sources and linked, cruise prices are verified on the cruise line’s own website the day we publish, and we earn no commissions. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will correct it. Last updated November 7, 2026.

Yes, a tour boat really did try to have a cruise ship arrested. On October 1, 2026, the owner of the Rhodes excursion catamaran King of Rhodes asked a Greek court to seize Virgin Voyages’ Scarlet Lady and stop her leaving, claiming at least €400,000 in damage. She sailed at 5 p.m. the same day anyway, because her insurer, Skuld, handed over a letter of guarantee.

What happened next: nothing yet. The claim is listed for a hearing at the Rhodes court on February 23, 2027, according to Dimokratiki and Cruise Hive. As of November 7, 2026, we’ve found no later report and no public statement from Virgin Voyages.

It sounds like a farce. It’s routine maritime law.

The white and blue catamaran King of Rhodes approaching the quay beside the much larger cruise ship Blue Sapphire in the Port of Rhodes, evening light
The catamaran King of Rhodes coming alongside in the Port of Rhodes in August 2024, next to the moored cruise ship Blue Sapphire. Photo: Pjotr Mahhonin, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

A Gale, a Snapped Rope and a €400,000 Claim

Just after 8:15 p.m. on September 30, waves parted several of Scarlet Lady’s mooring lines in Rhodes and she touched a catamaran and two small boats, Skai reported. Early reports suggested little harm (our story on that night).

The owner tells it differently. Dimokratiki says the cruise ship hit King of Rhodes at the stern and shoved her about 50 metres toward the Symi II (only Dimokratiki reports this). The claim lists damaged mooring fittings, a boarding ladder lost to the sea and a destroyed starboard platform protecting the propulsion. A haul-out is planned to check for hidden damage. Cruise Mummy says the €400,000 covers repairs, lost income and possibly chartering another boat to honour excursion contracts.

🛳️ The week's verified cruise deals, every Friday

Every fare checked on the cruise line's own site. We'll also send your free Cruise Survival Kit right away, with a printable packing checklist and money-saving cheat sheet.

Send me the deals →
WhenWhat happened
Wed Sep 30, after 8:15 p.m.Mooring lines part in a gale. Scarlet Lady makes contact with King of Rhodes and two small boats.
Thu Oct 1The catamaran owner asks the Rhodes court for a precautionary seizure and a ban on the ship leaving. Claim: at least €400,000.
Thu Oct 1, 5 p.m.Skuld delivers a letter of guarantee. Scarlet Lady sails.
Tue Feb 23, 2027Hearing listed at the single-member court of first instance in Rhodes.
Compiled by Cruise Chaos from Dimokratiki, Skai, Cruise Hive and Cruise Mummy. Cruise Hive and Cruise Mummy call the departure on time, though the itinerary had her leaving on September 30. Our first story covers why she stayed.
The catamaran King of Rhodes speeding across deep blue water past a rocky shore
King of Rhodes, a Sea Dreams day-trip catamaran, arriving in Rhodes in August 2023. Photo: Pjotr Mahhonin, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

How Can a Tour Boat “Arrest” a Cruise Ship?

On land, a dented car means swapping insurance details. At sea, the other “car” may be in another country by morning, under a foreign flag and owned by a company you’ve never heard of (Dimokratiki names VC Ship One Limited). So maritime law lets a claimant hold the ship itself as security.

Greek law ties this to the 1952 Brussels Arrest Convention, a Greek shipping lawyer explains in Global Law Experts. The convention’s list of claims that justify an arrest opens with “damage caused by any ship either in collision or otherwise”, which is the catamaran’s claim exactly. Article 1(2) defines arrest as “the detention of a ship by judicial process to secure a maritime claim.”

The key word is secure. An arrest isn’t a verdict; nobody has been found at fault. Greece moves fast, too: the lawyer says that in urgent Piraeus cases “the entire cycle from filing to physical detention of a vessel can be completed within 24 hours.”

The Letter That Set Her Free

The convention builds in the way out. Article 5 says the court “shall permit the release of the ship upon sufficient bail or other security being furnished.”

Shipping’s favourite security is a letter from the ship’s protection and indemnity (P&I) club. Skuld’s own explainer calls a letter of undertaking “in effect, a form of guarantee issued by the Club”. Skuld says “it is not at all unusual for it to be issued in a matter of hours,” with “no fee payable by the assured,” and that once accepted the claim “is secured on a without prejudice basis, and the vessel will be released.” The Greek lawyer calls them the “industry standard in shipping disputes.”

The letter admits nothing. It swaps the ship for a promise: if the court finds Scarlet Lady liable, Skuld pays. We haven’t seen it, so we can’t say what it covers.

When No Letter Comes: Crystal Symphony

In January 2022, as Crystal Cruises suspended its ocean voyages, fuel supplier Peninsula Petroleum Far East sued in Florida over more than $4.6 million, $1.2 million of it tied to Crystal Symphony, ABC7/CNN reported. A judge issued an arrest warrant ahead of her Saturday arrival in Miami.

She went to Bimini instead. Crystal said about 300 passengers were ferried to Fort Lauderdale on Sunday, and that this “was not the conclusion to our guests’ vacation we originally planned for” (ABC7/CNN). The AP, via Afar, said reports gave 300 or 700, and quoted a passenger’s Facebook post: “We all feel we were abducted by luxurious pirates!”

The white cruise ship Crystal Symphony sailing head-on towards the camera under a blue sky with clouds
Crystal Symphony in the Stockholm archipelago in 2007. In January 2022 she skipped Miami, where an arrest warrant was waiting. Photo: EnDumEn, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Scarlet Lady, Rhodes, 2026Crystal Symphony, Miami, 2022
Who wanted her heldOwner of a damaged catamaranA fuel supplier owed money
ClaimAt least €400,000$1.2 million for this ship ($4.6 million+ in all)
What stopped an arrestA letter of guarantee from SkuldNo security reported; she avoided the port
What passengers noticedA late departure from RhodesBimini, then a rough ferry ride to Florida
Compiled by Cruise Chaos from Dimokratiki, Cruise Mummy, ABC7/CNN and the AP via Afar (all linked above).

The difference is whether someone solvent stands behind the ship. A collision claim against a ship with a P&I club is paperwork. An unpaid bill at a line running out of money is a passenger problem.

What Your Ticket Says, Including a Right You Signed Away

Virgin’s ticket contract (version 6.5, October 7, 2025, still live on November 7, 2026) names this scenario. Section 9.1 lists “seizure of Vessel by legal process” among events beyond its control, and says the line “shall not be liable for any claim whatsoever by Guest, including but not limited to any losses, compensation or refund” when it cancels or deviates.

Then section 16.6: “The Guest waives the right to arrest the Vessel or any other vessel operated or chartered by the Carrier,” and a guest who causes an arrest “shall be liable to the Carrier for all lost revenue and other losses or claims.” The catamaran owner never bought a ticket, so they can try. You’ve signed that right away, whether or not every court would enforce it.

The red stern of Virgin Voyages' Scarlet Lady with the Virgin logo, seen past a harbour tug
Scarlet Lady’s stern, with her port of registry, Nassau, painted on it, in Liverpool in February 2020. Photo: The Silver Novice, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Should a Ship Arrest Worry You?

Rarely. With a P&I club behind her, a ship settles a claim like this with a letter, and you may never hear of it on board. If it does disrupt your cruise, don’t count on compensation: Virgin’s section 9.1 rules it out, so check your own line’s contract for similar wording. The real risk is a line in money trouble, as Crystal’s guests found. If a smaller line’s news is full of unpaid suppliers or suspended sailings, avoid paying in full far ahead, pay by credit card, and look for insurance that covers a supplier’s financial failure. Our guide to whether you need cruise insurance shows what to check.

Cruise Chaos earns nothing from cruise lines and doesn’t run booking affiliate links. Every source is linked above. The damage figures are the catamaran owner’s claim, not a court finding. Correction, November 7, 2026: earlier versions said a passenger told the AP the “luxurious pirates” line (the AP quoted a Facebook post) and credited Crystal’s statement and the 300 figure to the AP (they’re in ABC7/CNN; the AP said 300 or 700). Spot an error? Tell us and we’ll correct it in the open.

Got a cruise story like this?

Something wild, strange or funny happened on your sailing? Tell us what happened. We read every story, fact-check it, and email you before anything is published.

Share your story →

Keep Reading


Sources

🛳️ The Week’s Verified Cruise Deals, Every Friday

Every fare checked on the cruise line’s own site. Join the crew and we’ll also send your free Cruise Survival Kit right away, with a printable packing checklist and money-saving cheat sheet.

We’ll never send you spam or share your email address.
Find out more in our Privacy Policy.

🛳️ The Week’s Verified Cruise Deals, Every Friday

Every fare checked on the cruise line’s own site. Join the crew and we’ll also send your free Cruise Survival Kit right away, with a printable packing checklist and money-saving cheat sheet.

We’ll never send you spam or share your email address.
Find out more in our Privacy Policy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *